Guide · hard drive

Signs your hard drive is failing.

Hard disks rarely fail without warning; in most cases, the drive will have given some indication of its impending failure for a period of days or weeks before it failed. Spotting these indications early (a strange new noise, a performance slowdown, an unopenable file) provides an opportunity to back up data calmly as opposed to frantically attempting to recover lost data. This article provides the most important indicators of potential failure and actions to take upon their identification.

Free 48-hour diagnostic
Handled in-house
Only pay if we recover your data, on most jobs
// in short

Catch it early.

When a hard drive begins to fail, it’s operating on borrowed time. There are two types of indicators: those that indicate “back up now while you still can” and those that indicate “stop using it immediately”. Identifying which is which is what saves your data.

Warns
Usually, before dying
Back up
At the first sign
Stop
If it makes noises
Act
Sooner beats later
// why it matters

Drives usually warn you first.

A hard drive is a mechanical device. Mechanical devices tend to deteriorate over time as opposed to simply disappearing. Over time sectors will become unusable, bearings will wear out, heads will become weak, and each stage produces noticeable symptoms. The trap is dismissing these symptoms as “the computer being slow” until the entire drive crashes and causes loss of all data.

The initial failure signs should be considered a countdown. While the drive is still mostly readable, you can easily back up or recover your data if you take action; waiting will require a lab to recover the residual data.

// noises

Sounds that mean trouble.

Noise is the most urgent indication of problems. A clicking noise generally indicates the read/write heads cannot properly position themselves; a grinding or scraping noise can indicate that at least one of the heads has made contact with the magnetic platters; a repetitive buzzing or beeping noise can indicate that the hard disk’s motor is having trouble spinning up the disks. These are all mechanical failures in progress.

All of these symptoms fall into the “stop now” category. If a drive begins producing new sounds or noise while in operation, you need to turn it off. Do not attempt to back up your data (this may damage the heads and cause them to scratch against the platter surfaces, so that what was recoverable data becomes unrecoverable). This is the one symptom where attempting to copy your data off can do more harm than good.

// software signs

Slow, freezing, and vanishing files.

Not all warnings can be heard. A drive that’s developing bad sectors will get slower and slower: opening files will become very time consuming, accessing certain folders will freeze the machine and attempts to copy data will stall, due to the drive constantly trying to read unreadable parts of the disk. Files and/or folders may also disappear, become corrupted or have their names mangled. This indicates the file system is failing.

There are also error messages you can receive, for example “this drive needs to be formatted”, a drive suddenly showing as RAW or empty, or repeated read/write errors. If the drive is still accessible, now is the time to back up the most important files first, but crucially, do not click format if asked.

// detection

When the drive comes and goes.

An intermittent drive is a dying drive. If a drive does not always appear, randomly disconnects itself or requires multiple attempts to connect to a computer, something is dying, often the heads, the electronic components or (with external drives) the connection. While it might be tempting to continue re-attaching until the device finally connects again, with each attempt you are putting additional stress on a drive that’s already having problems.

If it is still appearing occasionally, save copies of your important files as soon as it appears again. If it is no longer showing up at all (especially when combined with a lack of sound, or clicks), stop trying to fix this issue. It is time to have your data recovered.

// SMART

What SMART tells you — and doesn’t.

Modern hard disks keep track of their own “health” using a system called SMART (Self-Monitoring, Analysis and Reporting Technology). The SMART logs will show metrics such as how many reallocated sectors (failing sectors swapped for good spare sectors) are on the disk and how many pending sectors (sectors failing but not yet reallocated). There are free utilities available that can extract these values. Any increase in the number of reallocated sectors, or a “back up your drive” warning from Windows, is a serious red flag.

The SMART logs are no guarantee, however. Many drives, especially with sudden mechanical or electronic problems, have a perfect SMART log until they completely fail. Do not rely solely upon SMART logs to determine whether your drive is healthy.

// what to do

What to do at the first sign.

Determine whether the sign is “software” type (slow reading, occasional errors, a SMART warning) or “hardware” type (noise, not detected). If it’s a software-type sign and the drive still reads, back up all data immediately, in priority order with critical files first, then replace the drive. Do not rely on an error-prone device for anything, no matter how good it may seem.

If it is a hardware problem, such as a noise, or the failure to even detect the drive, stop using it. Do not run any additional software. Do not continue to try and use it. Each subsequent attempt could cause further irreparable damage. At that point, a diagnostic will be able to tell you what is potentially recoverable before you spend anything.

// faq

Common questions.

The questions we receive most from customers regarding failing disks.

Very possibly. Slow access to and freezing when attempting to open files are very common symptoms of an area on the hard drive that has become damaged or unreadable (a bad sector), where the drive will keep trying to read this same bad sector. Back up all of your important data immediately if you are able to still access the data on the failing drive, then replace the drive. If it’s also making strange noises or disconnecting itself while in use, do not continue to try to use it: treat it as a failure rather than a slowdown.

No, that’s the exception. A noise always indicates a physical failure of some sort. Running the drive to copy files off can let the heads “score” the platters, causing permanent loss. Shut down the unit and have it evaluated. For the silent (software) type warnings, back up data. For the noisy type, stop now.

Not necessarily. SMART is a useful early warning system. However, drives can and do fail without a single error on their SMART report, especially from a sudden mechanical failure or a sudden electronic failure. If you are experiencing other symptoms (e.g., the drive makes noises, it freezes, files disappear), trust these symptoms over the SMART report. Back up your data regardless.

// drive failing?

Spotted the signs? Don’t wait for the end.

If your drive remains readable, back up your data immediately. If your drive starts making noise, or if your drive drops out or disconnects, stop now. Get a quote first, by phone or with our quote form, and send it in for a free diagnostic; we’ll give you an honest evaluation of how much data is recoverable. We accept your drive by post from anywhere in the UK, or you can drop it off to us at our location in Belfast (no appointment needed).

Call us — 028 9002 0144
Mon–Fri · 9am–5:30pm · No fix, no fee
Start a free diagnostic →
028 9002 0144